5/18/25 Update: Rather than these rambling thoughts, I encourage interested readers to check out my lengthier essay examining this topic.
As part of a reading group, for our last meeting I selected the following texts: “Mama’s Baby, Papa’s Maybe: An American Grammar Book,” by Hortense Spillers; “Afro-Pessimism: The Unclear Word,” by Jared Sexton; and, “The Social Life of Social Death: On Afro-Pessimism and Black Optimism,” also by Jared Sexton. As part of our meetings, those who choose the readings for the week have to do a written response as to how the readings incorporate into their research interests in general. In discussion with the reading group crew, I’ve decided to publish my response publicly in an effort to move our endeavor forward. If you’re interested in joining our group, reach out to me. The only requirements being that you’re bilingual (Spanish/English) and that you’re down to burn this all to the ground.
As I grapple with the three texts we read for this week, I cannot but help view them – as I am currently viewing everything – through the lens of Palestine. Therefore, I’m interested in doing what Frank Wilderson firmly disavows: a comparative reading of Palestine through the lens of Afro-Pessimism. I believe that doing so can offer insights on the current situation in Palestine and also on the arguments put forward by Spillers and Sexton. I want to acknowledge that to do so does great injustice to both narratives and subjects. Despite appreciable claims of Black-Palestinian solidarity, they cannot be conflated along the lines of historical experience nor ontological construction. At least not linearly nor literally. I believe metaphorically, however, there are openings or sites for exploration that I wish to delve into here.
Continue reading




